Assessing the effects of fish stock management on Cape gannet foraging behaviour in South Africa
- Strydom, Zanri, Grémillet, David, Pichegru, Lorien
- Authors: Strydom, Zanri , Grémillet, David , Pichegru, Lorien
- Date: 2023-12
- Subjects: Gannets -- South Africa , Birds of prey -- Behavior -- South Africa , Fish stock assessment
- Language: English
- Type: Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/62622 , vital:72887
- Description: Seabirds are one of the most threatened groups of birds under both marine and terrestrial pressures. Among seabirds, the Cape gannet Morus capensis is a southern African endemic species facing several pressures of anthropogenic origin, including competition with industrial fisheries on small pelagic fish stocks. Cape gannets, being a long-lived species that is sensitive to environmental changes, are sentinels of change in oceanic environments granting it important to understand which factors influence their foraging behaviour and breeding outputs. For example, factors like age can result in a loss of physical capabilities which can lead to behavioral compensation and subsequent changes in chick provisioning rates and amounts. With the current fisheries management the fish stocks are continually decreasing, indicating the importance of an updated fine-scale assessment on the spatiotemporal overlap between foraging gannets and fisheries. The first objective of this thesis was to determine the influence of adult Cape gannets’ age and sex on their foraging characteristics and energy expenditure during foraging. I equipped chick-rearing Cape gannets of known age and sex with a 3D accelerometer and GPS device. Foraging effort (trip duration, foraging path and maximum distance to the nest) did not differ between sexes nor with age in Cape gannets. Both sexes rested less on the water with age. Aging females also spent more time in flight than males. The age- and sexual differences in energy expenditure prevalent in our study might reflect niche and/or risk partitioning strategies to ensure adequate provisioning to the chick. The second objective of this thesis was to determine the influence of fisheries catch rates, sardine and anchovy biomass, and adult foraging effort on chick growth rates in Cape gannets, using a long-term dataset collected between 2005 and 2020 on Malgas Island. I equipped chick-rearing adults with a GPS device and I weighed the chicks for between 3 to 6 increments to calculate the average daily mass increment. Of all the variables, foraging trip duration was the main determinant of daily growth rates, with chicks benefitting from parents’ shorter foraging trip durations. Chicks tended to grow slower when fisheries catch of sardine and anchovy were higher, possibly an effect of competition with fisheries. Chicks also grew faster when fish biomass was higher. This long-term monitoring demonstrated the possible effect of food competition between Cape gannets and fisheries, with negative impacts on gannet fitness as determined via chick growth rates. The third objective of this thesis was to determine the influence of both the biomass and fisheries catch rates of sardine and anchovy on Cape gannet foraging effort at a spatial and temporal scale. This was achieved by equipping a total of 668 chick-rearing Cape gannets with a GPS device. With an increase in fisheries catch there was an increase in the birds’ foraging effort. To reduce competition between the gannets and fisheries, the gannets’ core foraging areas seldomly overlapped with the fisheries catch locations, at the cost of the gannets’ increased foraging effort. One method to halt the Cape gannet population decline would be to conserve the fish resources close to the breeding colonies. This would reduce the birds’ foraging whereby increasing their fitness. Safeguarding small pelagic fish to ensure the perseverance of the remaining Benguela seabird populations, would lead to preserving the Benguela marine ecosystem as a whole. My study provided new insight into effects of fish stock management on Cape gannet foraging behaviour in South Africa, and the need for adequate management to ensure population persistence. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, School of Environmental Sciences, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-12
- Authors: Strydom, Zanri , Grémillet, David , Pichegru, Lorien
- Date: 2023-12
- Subjects: Gannets -- South Africa , Birds of prey -- Behavior -- South Africa , Fish stock assessment
- Language: English
- Type: Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10948/62622 , vital:72887
- Description: Seabirds are one of the most threatened groups of birds under both marine and terrestrial pressures. Among seabirds, the Cape gannet Morus capensis is a southern African endemic species facing several pressures of anthropogenic origin, including competition with industrial fisheries on small pelagic fish stocks. Cape gannets, being a long-lived species that is sensitive to environmental changes, are sentinels of change in oceanic environments granting it important to understand which factors influence their foraging behaviour and breeding outputs. For example, factors like age can result in a loss of physical capabilities which can lead to behavioral compensation and subsequent changes in chick provisioning rates and amounts. With the current fisheries management the fish stocks are continually decreasing, indicating the importance of an updated fine-scale assessment on the spatiotemporal overlap between foraging gannets and fisheries. The first objective of this thesis was to determine the influence of adult Cape gannets’ age and sex on their foraging characteristics and energy expenditure during foraging. I equipped chick-rearing Cape gannets of known age and sex with a 3D accelerometer and GPS device. Foraging effort (trip duration, foraging path and maximum distance to the nest) did not differ between sexes nor with age in Cape gannets. Both sexes rested less on the water with age. Aging females also spent more time in flight than males. The age- and sexual differences in energy expenditure prevalent in our study might reflect niche and/or risk partitioning strategies to ensure adequate provisioning to the chick. The second objective of this thesis was to determine the influence of fisheries catch rates, sardine and anchovy biomass, and adult foraging effort on chick growth rates in Cape gannets, using a long-term dataset collected between 2005 and 2020 on Malgas Island. I equipped chick-rearing adults with a GPS device and I weighed the chicks for between 3 to 6 increments to calculate the average daily mass increment. Of all the variables, foraging trip duration was the main determinant of daily growth rates, with chicks benefitting from parents’ shorter foraging trip durations. Chicks tended to grow slower when fisheries catch of sardine and anchovy were higher, possibly an effect of competition with fisheries. Chicks also grew faster when fish biomass was higher. This long-term monitoring demonstrated the possible effect of food competition between Cape gannets and fisheries, with negative impacts on gannet fitness as determined via chick growth rates. The third objective of this thesis was to determine the influence of both the biomass and fisheries catch rates of sardine and anchovy on Cape gannet foraging effort at a spatial and temporal scale. This was achieved by equipping a total of 668 chick-rearing Cape gannets with a GPS device. With an increase in fisheries catch there was an increase in the birds’ foraging effort. To reduce competition between the gannets and fisheries, the gannets’ core foraging areas seldomly overlapped with the fisheries catch locations, at the cost of the gannets’ increased foraging effort. One method to halt the Cape gannet population decline would be to conserve the fish resources close to the breeding colonies. This would reduce the birds’ foraging whereby increasing their fitness. Safeguarding small pelagic fish to ensure the perseverance of the remaining Benguela seabird populations, would lead to preserving the Benguela marine ecosystem as a whole. My study provided new insight into effects of fish stock management on Cape gannet foraging behaviour in South Africa, and the need for adequate management to ensure population persistence. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, School of Environmental Sciences, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-12
The geographic stock structure of chokka squid, Loligo Reynaudi, and its implications for management of the fishery
- Van der Vyver, Johan Samuel Frederik
- Authors: Van der Vyver, Johan Samuel Frederik
- Date: 2014
- Subjects: Squids -- Geographical distribution , Loligo fisheries -- Africa, Southern , Fishery management -- Africa, Southern , Squids -- Africa, Southern , Squid fisheries -- Africa, Southern , Loliginidae -- Africa, Southern , Fish stock assessment
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5363 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1012973
- Description: It is currently hypothesised that the chokka squid (Loligo reynaudi) consist of a single stock. This was tested through a spatial comparison of the morphology of this species. Forty three morphometric characters were measured from 1079 chokka squid collected from three regions: the south coast of South Africa, the west coast of South Africa, and southern Angola. While no significant differences were found for the hard body parts, results from discriminant function analyses showed the soft body morphometric characters from each of the three regions differed, with an overall correct classification rate of 100% for males and 99% for females in all three regions. Due to the existing model being used to assess the resource currently being updated it was not feasible to apply this model to the area-disaggregated data from this study. Rather, the CPUE trends and catches from the area-disaggregated data were compared against those of the area-aggregated data, as a first attempt to discern any appreciable differences which would suggest the use of disaggregated data in future assessments. Both the trawl and jig CPUE trends from the area-disaggregated analysis differed only slightly from those of the area-aggregated data. Similarly, the spring and autumn biomass trends for the main spawning area (east of 22°E) followed the same trends as for the full area. It is therefore concluded that there is currently no need to assess the resource on an area-disaggregated basis.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2014
- Authors: Van der Vyver, Johan Samuel Frederik
- Date: 2014
- Subjects: Squids -- Geographical distribution , Loligo fisheries -- Africa, Southern , Fishery management -- Africa, Southern , Squids -- Africa, Southern , Squid fisheries -- Africa, Southern , Loliginidae -- Africa, Southern , Fish stock assessment
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5363 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1012973
- Description: It is currently hypothesised that the chokka squid (Loligo reynaudi) consist of a single stock. This was tested through a spatial comparison of the morphology of this species. Forty three morphometric characters were measured from 1079 chokka squid collected from three regions: the south coast of South Africa, the west coast of South Africa, and southern Angola. While no significant differences were found for the hard body parts, results from discriminant function analyses showed the soft body morphometric characters from each of the three regions differed, with an overall correct classification rate of 100% for males and 99% for females in all three regions. Due to the existing model being used to assess the resource currently being updated it was not feasible to apply this model to the area-disaggregated data from this study. Rather, the CPUE trends and catches from the area-disaggregated data were compared against those of the area-aggregated data, as a first attempt to discern any appreciable differences which would suggest the use of disaggregated data in future assessments. Both the trawl and jig CPUE trends from the area-disaggregated analysis differed only slightly from those of the area-aggregated data. Similarly, the spring and autumn biomass trends for the main spawning area (east of 22°E) followed the same trends as for the full area. It is therefore concluded that there is currently no need to assess the resource on an area-disaggregated basis.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2014
Optimisation of a sampling protocol for long-term monitoring of temperate reef fishes
- Authors: Bennett, Rhett Hamilton
- Date: 2008
- Subjects: Marine parks and reserves -- South Africa , Coastal zone management -- South Africa , Fishery management -- South Africa , Reef fishes -- South Africa , Fish communities -- South Africa , Fish stock assessment
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5309 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005154 , Marine parks and reserves -- South Africa , Coastal zone management -- South Africa , Fishery management -- South Africa , Reef fishes -- South Africa , Fish communities -- South Africa , Fish stock assessment
- Description: Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), the Ecosystem Approach to Fisheries management (EAF) and Integrated Coastal Management (ICM) have been identified as possible alternatives to traditional linefish management measures, which have largely failed. Monitoring and assessment of fish communities on a long-term basis is necessary, and will provide a means to evaluate the effectiveness of such management measures. Therefore, standardised protocols and optimal sampling methods for long-term monitoring (LTM) and assessment of coastal fish communities are essential. This study aimed to identify suitable methods and develop a protocol for assessment of inshore reef fish communities. A suitable location for evaluation of proposed methods was identified in the warm temperate biogeographical region of South Africa, encompassing the well-established Tsitsikamma Coastal National Park MPA and an adjacent exploited area. Chrysoblephus laticeps (roman) was identified as an indicator species for the study, as it has been well-studied and is well represented in the area. Underwater visual census (UVC) and controlled fishing were identified as suitable methods. UVC transects were found to be superior to point counts, in terms of sampling efficiency, variability, bias and required sample size. An effort of two angler hours per fishing station was shown to provide low catch variability, while at the same time a representative catch and low overall cost and required time. The methods were incorporated in a proposed sampling protocol, and evaluated. The methods were able to detect known differences between protected and exploited communities. It is recommended that LTM within protected areas, for detection of natural change, be focused on community-level indicators, while LTM in exploited areas, aimed at detection of anthropogenic change, be focused on species-level indicators. The proposed protocol with standardised methods will allow for comparisons across a network of LTM sites and provide the opportunity for a broad-scale assessment of the effects of environmental variables on reef fish stocks. The protocol developed in this study has application in other biogeographical regions in South Africa, and other parts of the world. Shift in the focus of much marine research, in South Africa and elsewhere, to LTM, highlights the relevance and timeous nature of this study.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2008
- Authors: Bennett, Rhett Hamilton
- Date: 2008
- Subjects: Marine parks and reserves -- South Africa , Coastal zone management -- South Africa , Fishery management -- South Africa , Reef fishes -- South Africa , Fish communities -- South Africa , Fish stock assessment
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Masters , MSc
- Identifier: vital:5309 , http://hdl.handle.net/10962/d1005154 , Marine parks and reserves -- South Africa , Coastal zone management -- South Africa , Fishery management -- South Africa , Reef fishes -- South Africa , Fish communities -- South Africa , Fish stock assessment
- Description: Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), the Ecosystem Approach to Fisheries management (EAF) and Integrated Coastal Management (ICM) have been identified as possible alternatives to traditional linefish management measures, which have largely failed. Monitoring and assessment of fish communities on a long-term basis is necessary, and will provide a means to evaluate the effectiveness of such management measures. Therefore, standardised protocols and optimal sampling methods for long-term monitoring (LTM) and assessment of coastal fish communities are essential. This study aimed to identify suitable methods and develop a protocol for assessment of inshore reef fish communities. A suitable location for evaluation of proposed methods was identified in the warm temperate biogeographical region of South Africa, encompassing the well-established Tsitsikamma Coastal National Park MPA and an adjacent exploited area. Chrysoblephus laticeps (roman) was identified as an indicator species for the study, as it has been well-studied and is well represented in the area. Underwater visual census (UVC) and controlled fishing were identified as suitable methods. UVC transects were found to be superior to point counts, in terms of sampling efficiency, variability, bias and required sample size. An effort of two angler hours per fishing station was shown to provide low catch variability, while at the same time a representative catch and low overall cost and required time. The methods were incorporated in a proposed sampling protocol, and evaluated. The methods were able to detect known differences between protected and exploited communities. It is recommended that LTM within protected areas, for detection of natural change, be focused on community-level indicators, while LTM in exploited areas, aimed at detection of anthropogenic change, be focused on species-level indicators. The proposed protocol with standardised methods will allow for comparisons across a network of LTM sites and provide the opportunity for a broad-scale assessment of the effects of environmental variables on reef fish stocks. The protocol developed in this study has application in other biogeographical regions in South Africa, and other parts of the world. Shift in the focus of much marine research, in South Africa and elsewhere, to LTM, highlights the relevance and timeous nature of this study.
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2008
- «
- ‹
- 1
- ›
- »